Auction engine: vendor answers and comparison (19 Nov)
Nov 19, 2026 · Povio
Summary
ATG is out of our use case, Basta is a valid choice at 1–2% of hammer with price protection to negotiate, and building our own stays our lean at a ballpark of about one month of work for a timed-only engine.
- ATG: offers only full white-label solutions, no engine for our own apps, LivePayments required, and pricing deferred to an introductory call.
- Basta: fits our own apps, keeps accounts and data control with RedBird by contract, priced as a share of hammer that grows with sales.
- Bidpath: no reply yet.
- Build: no maintained open-source engine to adopt; we start from MIT-licensed building blocks. About one month covers the timed engine only; live bidding and the rest add to it.
ATG: out of our use case
ATG is too restrictive for a marketplace that runs its own apps and owns its customers. From ATG's preliminary answers:
- No engine, only full white-label solutions. ATG does not provide an app with its White Label solution and offered no API or SDK for RedBird's own web and native apps. Bidding would run on an ATG-hosted site, which is the route we ruled out.
- LivePayments required. Buyer payments would run through ATG, not RedBird's own payment provider.
- Pricing deferred to an introductory call. No price, model or range in writing.
- Lock-in. A 12-month contract that renews automatically unless cancelled 90 days before, and no exit terms: the contract is paid out.
Its one strength is confirmed: the same timed lot can be listed on LiveAuctioneers and the White Label site at once. That only matters if RedBird wants LiveAuctioneers bidders inside timed sales, which is parked until the Skydance term sheet.
Basta: a valid choice
Basta is a headless engine built to sit behind RedBird's own apps. Its answers cover RedBird's conditions on data by contract, and it offered a sandbox before signing.
How it is priced
- A share of completed hammer, usually 1–2%, depending on volume, scope and requirements.
- Hybrid options: a fixed subscription plus a percentage, and declining percentage tiers as volume grows.
- No implementation fee if Povio builds the integration end to end, with a shared Slack channel for support.
At the planning ranges we sent (10–20 sales a year, $500k–$2M hammer each), before tiers or a hybrid:
| Annual hammer | At 1% | At 2% |
|---|---|---|
| $500k | $5k a year | $10k a year |
| $1M | $10k a year | $20k a year |
| $5M (10 sales × $500k) | $50k a year | $100k a year |
| $15M (15 sales × $1M) | $150k a year | $300k a year |
| $40M (20 sales × $2M) | $400k a year | $800k a year |
Price protection is a contract question. Basta's enterprise contracts are usually multi-year, but it is open to a shorter first term, written price protection, and defined renewal and termination terms. That is how Basta can answer the concern about prices rising after 12 months: a cap on the fee and on renewals, in writing.
Data and exit
- RedBird keeps its own accounts and sign-in; Basta takes short-lived bidder tokens issued with RedBird's user IDs.
- RedBird is the controller and Basta the processor under Basta's data processing agreement. No marketing use of RedBird's data, and no use for other clients.
- After termination, data comes back as SQL/CSV, with the exit procedure agreed before signing.
- Payments stay on RedBird's own merchant account (Stripe supported); Basta handles orders, invoices and orchestration.
Limitations
- The fee grows with every sale. At $15M of hammer a year that is $150k–$300k, every year. A cap is the main ask.
- Bids, lots, registrations, results and invoices sit on Basta's servers (AWS, US East). Basta's terms also allow anonymised, aggregated usage analytics.
- A small company. Basta has about 20 staff and is majority-owned by Gangverk, so continuity is a risk. Code or data escrow is worth asking for.
- Multi-year terms by default. A short first term has to be negotiated.
- Scaling limits to confirm. Its client API documents 400 requests per 10 seconds per IP address and endpoint; enterprise limits and peak bids in a hot closing minute are still to ask.
- SOC 2 status not confirmed; Basta offered to cover it in the technical review.
- LiveAuctioneers and Invaluable: its clerk tool takes their bidding and can import winning bids, but how automatic that is will be shown on the call.
- The LiveAuctioneers data rule still applies to buyers who win there, as for any engine.
Bidpath: waiting for a reply
We asked Bidpath whether SAM can run engine-only behind RedBird's own apps through its API Suite, plus pricing, data ownership, LiveAuctioneers and Invaluable, payments, contract terms and a sandbox. No reply yet.
What we know publicly: Bidpath sells a full auction suite, used by Propstore as a separately hosted site, with an API Suite available through sales and no published price. If engine-only use is not possible, Bidpath drops out for the same reason as ATG.
Building our own: open-source options and effort
No maintained open-source auction engine is ready to adopt. What exists are building blocks we can start from. Checked by cloning each repository on 19 Nov:
| Project | What it gives us | Licence and activity | Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| RBBB | A written specification of timed proxy bidding with a full audit trail, language-neutral test scenarios, and a Ruby reference engine; linked soft close added in October | MIT; last change 10 Nov 2026; pre-stable, "not production ready" | Our acceptance tests |
| auctionanything | A small TypeScript proxy-bidding engine: max bids, increments, extension on late bids | MIT; one-site production use; last change 23 Oct 2026 | Starting rule set |
| GoAuction | A Go service: Postgres with optimistic locking, anti-sniping, WebSocket updates, OpenAPI, rate limiting; no proxy bids or reserves | MIT; 20 commits, last May 2026 | Service patterns |
| AURUM Auctions (ngothoaidev) | The closest design to ours: TypeScript and Postgres, proxy bidding with per-lot locks, idempotent bids, outbox, settlement worker, SSE | No licence: all rights reserved; last change 9 Nov 2026 | Design reference only, unless the author licenses it |
| hmellor/auction-website | A React and Firebase single-event site | MIT | Not a base: no server-side bidding |
The approach: a clean service in our own stack, with AURUM's design (row locks, idempotency keys, an outbox, a settlement worker), auctionanything's rules adapted to RedBird's increments and closing rule, and RBBB's scenarios as the tests it must pass.
Effort: a super ballpark of about one month of work, for a timed-only engine, built alongside the apps. It depends on the full feature set for V1.
Comparison matrix
| Build our own | Basta | ATG White Label | Bidpath | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fits our own web and native apps | Yes | Yes: GraphQL, WebSockets, React and React Native SDKs | No: full white-label only, no app or SDK | Asked: engine-only via API Suite? |
| Pricing model | Build effort, then upkeep; no per-sale fee | 1–2% of hammer; hybrid and declining tiers offered | Deferred to an introductory call | Asked |
| Cost as sales grow | Flat | Grows with hammer: $150k–$300k a year at $15M | Unknown | Unknown |
| Price protection | Not needed | Negotiable, in writing | Not offered | Asked |
| Contract and exit | None | Multi-year by default, shorter first term negotiable; SQL/CSV data return | 12 months, auto-renews, 90 days' notice; no exit terms | Asked |
| Bidder accounts and data | RedBird | RedBird holds accounts; Basta processes bids and results under a DPA | ATG-hosted site | Asked |
| Payments | RedBird's own provider | RedBird's own provider | LivePayments required | Asked |
| Timed sale on LiveAuctioneers too | No | No | Yes | Asked |
| Live sales with outside platforms | Clerk consoles, later phase | Clerk tool takes LiveAuctioneers and Invaluable bids; automation to confirm | LiveAuctioneers built in | Asked |
| Scaling | Ours to design and load-test | Documented API limits; enterprise limits to confirm | Not answered | Asked |
| Main risk | Delivery and upkeep | Fee growth and vendor continuity | Lock-in and no fit | No reply |
| Status | Recommended | Valid choice | Out | Waiting |